There is a saying that there are two certainties in life: death
and taxes. While Australia doesn't have a death duty as such,
certain income and capital transactions that occur as a consequence
of a person's death may trigger a tax event - if not immediately,
in the future.
Generally, if someone dies and they have investments and assets
such as shares, there is no deemed disposal of those investments or
assets. However, if they pass them to the beneficiary of the
estate, then the tax profile of those investments will be inherited
by the beneficiary.
While it may not always be possible to avoid these de facto
death taxes, it may be possible to reduce or defer them depending
on how you plan your estate.
The use of trusts - including a discretionary trust such as a
testamentary trust or a family trust - is one way to ensure that
your assets are left according to your wishes and with minimal tax
consequences.
According to Mark Robinson, estate planning lawyer with
Anderssen Lawyers, with careful planning it is possible to maximise
the benefits to your loved ones.
"It is not about avoiding paying tax but minimising or deferring
any unexpected tax liabilities," he says.
Capital Gains Tax
When it comes to inheriting assets, the biggest tax issue facing
the beneficiary will be capital gains tax (CGT). Unless a person
knows they are going to die and sells their assets prior to death
and then gifts the proceeds, it can be hard for any beneficiary to
totally avoid CGT.
The exception is the family home. Where a person inherits the
principal place of residence of the deceased and disposes of it
within two years of death, then it can be sold free of CGT.
The inheritance of assets other than the family home, such as
shares, carry different rules depending on when the deceased
acquired them.
If the asset held by the deceased was bought before September
20, 1985, then it is deemed to be pre-CGT.
According to Craig Holland, tax services partner with Deloitte,
when the pre-CGT asset passes to a beneficiary it loses its pre-CGT
status, however the beneficiary will obtain a market-value cost
base determined at the time of death.
If it is an asset acquired after September 19, 1985, and so is
post-CGT, the implications for a beneficiary can be worse, says
Holland.
"In this case, the beneficiary inherits the deceased taxpayer's
cost base, not a market-value cost base ... the beneficiary
inherits an asset with an unrealised gain," he says.
Self-managed super fund
One of the big attractions of a self-managed superannuation fund
(SMSF) is that members can hold income-earning assets such as
property and shares and control their own investment and estate
planning strategy.
Basically, if a member of a super fund died and property or
other assets were transferred to a beneficiary, the tax outcome
would be determined by whether the assets were transferred to a
dependant or non-dependant. If the assets went to a dependant -
someone who relied on the deceased for financial support - then no
tax would be payable.
If the assets went to a non-dependant - such as an adult child -
then there would be an immediate tax liability of up to 16.5 per
cent of the property's value.
In some situations the SMSF may also incur a CGT liability in
effecting a transfer of the assets to the beneficiary.
The national technical manager with Taxpayers Australia, Roger
Timms, says the people exposed to tax are those who are sending
their benefits to someone who is not a dependant.
"Where it becomes unfair is that someone who knows they are
going to die could take the money out tax-free if they are at least
60 years of age and then gift the asset tax-free to the
beneficiary, whereas those without that opportunity will have tax
reduce the value of the estate," Timms says.
Testamentary trusts
A testamentary trust can come into existence under a person's
will and comes into effect when that person dies.
Its main benefits are the protection of assets by not placing
those assets in the hands of individual beneficiaries who may be
exposed to risk.
Deloitte's Holland says a big advantage of putting assets into a
testamentary trust is the assets are held in the name of the trust
and not the beneficiary.
When income is generated within the trust and distributed from
the trust to minors it can be done so without incurring the
pecuniary rates of tax. Under a trust environment, the income from
the trusts can be distributed in a tax-effective manner.
When the income is earned by minors outside a testamentary trust
environment, the minor would incur a tax rate of 66 cents in the
dollar on amounts between $416 and $1446, whereas if the assets
were inside a testamentary trust the tax rate would be at the adult
marginal rate, which could be a lot less.
Robinson adds that a testamentary trust gives the following
opportunities: an incentive to invest their inheritance through a
tax-effective structure that permits income and capital gains to be
shared with dependants; the opportunity to save tax on the income
and capital gains earned from the invested inheritance; and
enhanced protection for the inherited assets in the event that any
of the beneficiaries are involved in legal proceedings, like
bankruptcy or divorce.
One of the certainties of life
It is one thing to have enough life insurance to meet the needs
of loved ones left behind. Just imagine if a significant chunk of
any life insurance pay-out had to be paid straight to the tax
office.
Mark Robinson (pictured), estate planning lawyer with Anderssen
Lawyers, says while it makes sense for most people to carry their
life insurance within their super, there comes a point when they
should look to separating the two for estate planning purposes.
"If a spouse dies and the remaining spouse has life insurance
within their superannuation, which they were planning to leave to a
non-dependent beneficiary, then perhaps it should be taken out of
the superannuation," Robinson says.
"When superannuation is paid to a beneficiary it is treated as
having concessional and non-concessional components which attract
different rates of tax," he says. "Life insurance within your
superannuation has a tax regime of its own and is taxed at 30 per
cent rather than at 15 per cent, which means a good hunk could be
paid in tax by certain beneficiaries."
Robinson says the death of a spouse would be the natural trigger
point for reviewing an estate plan, particularly in blended
families.
If you own the life insurance policy outside of your super fund,
the proceeds can go into your estate or be apportioned to any
nominated beneficiary and there is no risk of having to pay tax,
unlike if it was within your superannuation.