When David Chalke's three children left school they were - ever
so gently - pushed out of the family home. The children spent a
year or two in university halls of residence, then rented houses
near the uni - bankrolled by Chalke while they were still
studying.
"We bribed them out of the house," laughs Chalke, a social
analyst who compiles the annual AustraliaSCAN survey. But he notes
that his baby boomer contemporaries increasingly are not getting
rid of their adult children, even with bribes.
Data from the 2006 census show 38 per cent of 20- to
29-year-olds still live at home, compared with 30 per cent in 2001
and 21 per cent in 1976.
The trend has spawned some clever labels, including helicopter
kids (hovering around the family home), boomerang kids (leaving
then coming back) and kippers (kids in parents' pockets eroding
retirement savings).
It's a predominantly middle-class phenomenon, according to
demographer and author Bernard Salt, because higher-income baby
boomers tend to have big houses and the cash flow to support adult
children, their live-in lovers and several cars.
"Up to 24, it's probably fair enough these days because of the
HECS debts," says Salt, who has two children, aged 18 and 21,
living at home while they study. "Really, the education phase has
moved beyond high school. But after 25, it's hard to argue there's
a legitimate reason to be at home."
His analysis of census data shows 18 per cent of 25- to
29-year-olds haven't fled the nest - and in some affluent outer
suburbs of Melbourne and Sydney, it is more than 50 per cent.
Plenty of reasons are offered: soaring house prices in Sydney
and Melbourne have locked some first home buyers out of the market,
while tight rental markets make leasing difficult.
Half of all school-leavers go on to some form of tertiary study,
which usually delays getting married, having children and buying a
house. Hence, the term "adultescents".
Dominic Thurbon, the managing director of gen Y consultancy The
Centre for Skills Development, has another theory: "Gen Y like
their parents. They've been parented from positions of friendship,
so it has been a more collegial, collaborative home environment."
As for the baby boomers, Salt says their official line is they want
their kids to move on but, unofficially, they need the ego-boost of
being at the centre of things. Sure, there's more washing, cooking
and cleaning - not to mention the cash sucked up - but Salt says
it's part of the boomer culture to be in control rather than
obsolete.
Whatever the reasons, the arrangement sounds like a win-win
scenario for parents and children.
But there is a dark side.
Despite the average gen Y having the same level of disposable
income as a one-child family, according to Thurbon, there is no
knowledge of the cost of living and the level of affluence required
to sustain a lifestyle.
Thurbon says: "It's feeding a general problem of financial
illiteracy amongst young people, where they have the income element
without the responsibility elements."
Chalke says: "If you get to your 30s and you haven't acquired
the mindset for financial skills such as budgeting, it gets a heck
of a lot more difficult. If you've had 10 years spending your
entire disposable income on entertainment, fashion and travel, you
won't have learnt how to cope with a changing world or how to do
without the $4 latte on the way to the office."
It's a problem the baby boomers are gradually waking up to,
according to Penelope Joye, an adviser with the Shadforth Financial
Group. "Many of my clients have financed themselves without the
benefit of wealthy parents and did it pretty tough, so they've been
happy to spoil their kids," she says.
"In retrospect, some clients now feel they did not do their
children any favours, as they feel the kids don't understand the
costs associated with their comfortable lifestyles."
The global financial crisis has shaken some parents into action.
Their super fund, share portfolio and house are worth a lot less
than a year ago, so they are watching their cash flow and feeling
less benevolent towards adult children.
"Clients have implemented strategies such as barring calls to
mobiles from the home phone, disconnecting Foxtel and not stocking
the fridge," Joye says.
But the real, long-term benefit will come from encouraging young
people to take responsibility for their finances, Joye believes.
Some clients bring children as young as 15 to Joye's seminars on
budgeting, regular savings plans and superannuation.
She also believes in charging board. "This encourages
responsibility and discipline and will stand them in good stead
when they are on their own."
Director of Haywood Financial Management, Scott Haywood, says
many of his baby boomer clients charge board of at least $50 a
week. If the parents see their offspring blowing their salary at
the pub every week, they will increase the board.
Some invest the board on the child's behalf or waive the payment
if the equivalent amount is invested directly by the child. Another
of Haywood's clients has gifted the board paid for two years back
to a daughter, who is moving out and needs to buy whitegoods and
furniture.
Financial planner Dickson Bonacci's principal adviser, Sylvia
Dickson, says her clients often mention the cost of their adult
children living at home. This may be direct costs, such as
increased food and utility bills, or indirect costs, such as being
unable to downsize.
"They will refer to it as short-term but in my experience it
very often extends beyond this timeframe," she says.
"Although they are good-humoured about it, there is usually some
impact on their lifestyle and their own plans are often deferred or
derailed by children still living at home."
The result, she believes, is a generation of young adults with
unrealistic expectations.
"They want to exceed their parents' achievements but in a
timeframe that is truncated by a reduced working life - settling
into careers later due to higher education, gap years, employment
changes, travel - deferring events such as home ownership, children
and education expenses until their 30s and 40s and then hoping to
retire at an earlier age."
As with Joye, Dickson says the key to teaching children
financial independence is education - especially about the benefits
of early accumulation of superannuation.
"For many, the current economic downturn will be their first
experience of an unfavourable environment. Most have enjoyed full
employment and an extended period of prosperity for their parents
through rising property prices and sharemarkets."
You might expect the economic downturn would lead to more kids
being flung from the nest earlier. Quite the opposite, the experts
say.
The baby boomers are aware their kids face a much tougher jobs
market.
"This will further reinforce the 'Let's stay at home' model,"
Chalke predicts, adding a tide of young expats will return after
losing their jobs in New York and London. But he also expects the
crisis to have a positive effect. " One of the good things . . . is
that it may lead to a simpler, more disciplined, less
self-indulgent lifestyle for baby boomers and their kids."
Salt agrees.
"It's time to grow up, you're twenty-bloody-nine," he says.
Mum knows best
Last year, Jane Taylor suggested to her eldest son, Mitchell,
then 20, that he might pay $50 a week board. He was working
full-time and she planned to put aside the board to give back to
him at a later date.
He decided if he was paying board, he may as well move out - and
he's now paying $250 to rent a small flat. "Silly boy," laughs
Jane.
Jane, 52, and her husband Chris, 54, have two other sons still
living in the couple's five-bedroom home on Sydney's North
Shore.
One son, aged 17, is still at school, while their 19-year-old,
Cameron, is working full-time at a financial advice company after
deferring a university course halfway through the academic
year.
They're happy not to charge Cameron board, although since he
started work he is expected to pay for the petrol, registration and
insurance on his car.
"I don't feel at this stage any need to charge rent," says Jane,
noting Cameron is not a spendthrift and uses all his spare cash to
build a share portfolio. She says he is also very helpful - mowing
the lawn, gardening, fixing the computer and driving his younger
brother around.
"Why show them the door?" she says. "The four of us live in
harmony and if you can help [your children], that's a good
thing."
The little household that could
Comedian Denise Scott devotes the final chapter of her book, All
That Happened At Number 26, to the joys and travails of living with
her two adult children.
She and her partner, John Lane, share their home in Melbourne's
north with Jordie, 24 - a singer-songwriter - and Bonnie, 22 - an
installation artist. Neither pays board; in fact, both sometimes
need to borrow money from their parents to finance their creative
pursuits.
"I really respect my kids' attempts to become artists and I'm
happy to support them financially," Scott says. "And I've always
had the belief that if I've got money and someone else hasn't, I
should share it."
The family gets on well, although the house has only one living
space - and Denise and Jordie both work from home.
Denise's main gripe is housework. The children do their own
washing and will cook if she hasn't done so but that's it - despite
Denise papering the house with notes about unpacking the dishwasher
and clearing the bench.
Money talks
* Encourage your adult children to take their finances
seriously. A seminar covering topics such as budgeting, regular
savings plans, superannuation and compound interest may help.
* Charge board and/or a contribution towards household bills.
Some parents "gift" the amount collected back when the child is
buying a house or a car.
Consider "deals" such as matching a saving of $1000, for
example, with an equal contribution into the child's superannuation
fund.
* Encourage your child to see a financial planner to discuss
strategies to make the best use of money, including the Government
co-contribution for super, first home owner's grant and nominating
a growth option for their super.
* Explain the benefits of contributing early to
superannuation.
Source: Financial planners Sylvia Dickson, Scott Haywood and
Penelope Joye.