Australians are experiencing their own personal credit crunch
and the impact is being felt well outside the low-income suburbs
where people have always battled to pay the bills, let alone
service a mortgage.
On one side of the tightening squeeze are rising home loan rates
and rents and overwhelming credit card debt; on the other side are
food inflation and the rising cost of petrol, not to mention
declining investment wealth and the burden of private school
fees.
Financial counsellors and credit industry analysts say that, as
a result, people in relatively high-income suburbs such as Bondi
and Woollahra in Sydney and St Kilda and Albert Park in Melbourne
have joined those feeling the squeeze.
"We are seeing middle-class people, people on reasonable incomes
- $100,000 a year," says Jan Pentland, a Victorian financial
counsellor who chairs the Australian Financial Counselling and
Credit Reform Association.
In Australia's most affluent city, Canberra, David Tennant, the
director of the Care Inc Financial Counselling Service, says: "I
have never seen the depth and breadth of financial difficulty that
is obviously being felt in the community. There are entirely new
groups of clients who are making contact with agencies like this
one."
In its 2005-06 annual report, Care Inc noted with concern that
people with incomes of more than $45,000 now accounted for 10 per
cent of its clients. "It was a big deal when it hit double
figures," Tennant says. In 2006-07, the figure was 15 per cent.
"Now, one in five people ... making contact with what is
essentially a crisis service are reporting incomes that are not
really very low," Tennant says. "They're in that moderate income
category, in the mortgage belt in one of the wealthiest cities in
one of the wealthiest countries in the world."
Fujitsu Consulting's mortgage stress research divides the home
loans market into 11 categories, such as "suburban mainstream". Its
latest report finds rising stress among "exclusive professionals" -
high-income earners who, according to its definition, can be
considered financially astute.
Among this group, those in "severe" stress - to the point where
they're talking about refinancing or even selling their homes - has
multiplied more than sixfold since September last year. That
compares with a fivefold increase in the overall number of people
considered to be experiencing severe stress.
"Exclusive professionals live in places like Bondi and Woollahra
- places you just wouldn't imagine," says Martin North, the
managing consulting director of Fujitsu Consulting Australia and
New Zealand.
"A lot of these people have big mortgages, a stock portfolio,
private school fees, margin loans. Some of these groups are also
experiencing significant issues because they're not getting income
from their stocks, they've had margin calls [and] the cost of
living is rising."
It's a similar story for "young affluents", where the number of
households in severe stress has quadrupled since September.
Of course, the group feeling the most pain, by far, is the
segment Fujitsu defines as the "disadvantaged fringe", along with
an increasing number of "young, growing families" - people Tennant
fears may be "crowded out" of access to support services.
Catriona Lowe, the joint chief executive of the Consumer Action
Law Centre in Victoria, says relaxation of lending standards -
whether for home loans or credit cards - is a major culprit in the
difficulties now being experienced.
"There seems to be this general comfort with debt that simply
didn't exist historically and we see that manifest in a whole range
of ways," Lowe says.
"People might be pulling out the credit card to pay for the
groceries because they're trying to get as many points as they can
- or because that's the [only] way they can afford to pay for the
groceries. It was just unheard of once upon a time to pull out the
credit card in that sort of scenario.
"We see people with multiple credit cards, we see people getting
into difficulty and receiving offers to increase the limits on
their credit cards - 'Here's a pre-approved offer, just tick the
boxes and sign at the bottom."'
She says many people have borrowed up to their limit for a home
loan but if "they'd sat down and worked out what they actually
needed to live on, they may have made a very different
decision".
Credit used to be something that a consumer would go out and
seek, Lowe says. "Now it's something that's sold to them - and
upsold. We have a bit of a 'super-size me' attitude to credit."
That's not to say consumers don't have personal responsibility
for their credit troubles "but it's also important to note that so
do the people who are doing the lending - there's definitely two
sides of the coin", Lowe says.
So what should people do if the sort of "tight" spot we all
experience from time to time turns into two, three or more months
of financial pressure?
The first steps should be to seek help and talk to your lenders,
counsellors say.
But don't accept any solution at face value - particularly the
quick and easy ones being offered by someone who will make money
from them. "What can appear the sensible solution really needs to
be very, very carefully managed and researched to make sure it is
the right solution," Lowe says.
Seek help
A recent survey conducted for credit information provider Veda
Advantage found that 16 per cent of people were finding it
difficult to meet repayments, yet only one in five of them had
sought help.
Pentland says people should act sooner rather than later. "As
soon as they're in the position where they're getting
over-the-limit fees or late-payment fees - or they're at risk of
getting them - then it's worth having a talk to the lender," she
says.
Contact the lender's call centre and ask to speak to the team
that specifically deals with financial hardship. "You'll get a more
sympathetic and useful hearing from them" than from general call
centre staff, she says.
Mainstream lenders such as banks, credit unions and building
societies operate under codes of practice that require them to put
hardship programs in place. In addition, the Uniform Consumer
Credit Code legally obliges lenders to make a "hardship variation"
to a loan in certain legally defined circumstances.
If the lender doesn't respond appropriately, there's redress
under the code of practice or credit code.
A spokesman for credit card provider American Express says: "The
sooner we can discuss a card member's problems, the more likely it
is we'll help them find a solution For example, we can freeze
interest, payments or fees, depending on the card member's needs,
to give them some time to get back on their feet.
"We may also freeze the credit limit and reduce it every time a
payment is made to ensure the card member can't get further into
debt."
Lowe says people should also seek independent advice - advice
not tied to commission payments or that generates fees and
charges.
Apart from the free counselling services, Veda Advantage
spokesman Chris Gration suggests middle- to high-income earners may
have access to advice from an accountant or financial planner -
though Tennant cautions they may not have specialist expertise when
it comes to hardship.
Lowe says groups such as hers give legal as well as financial
advice and sometimes people have rights they're unaware of. For
instance, if a lender didn't properly assess their capacity to pay,
they may be entitled to some relief.
Don't add to the debt
Counsellors are unanimous in saying the biggest mistake people
can make is to try to borrow their way out of trouble.
Veda Advantage is completing a survey of people either
considering bankruptcy or going through the process. Gration says
one finding is that about 90 per cent of those people - desperate
to find a solution - have sought further credit.
"I've seen the encouragement of 'churn' in the credit market
building over 10 years, with the consequence in the vast majority
of cases being that people end up owing more as they go through
that process," Tennant says.
"We've got to a point in this country where there's simply too
much debt being carried by people who can't afford it. Even more
debt is not the solution."
One scenario involves obtaining a new credit card, with the
offer of a lower rate or even zero interest on the balance
transferred from your old cards. That can make sense but in
counsellors' experience people neglect to cut up their old cards,
use them again and end up even deeper in debt.
Even if the cards are destroyed, lenders may tempt people with
new offers. "These are customers who have paid their debt, so they
will be offered credit again," Pentland says. "They need to be
really disciplined and not take those offers."
Consolidation
The same problem occurs when credit card debt is rolled into a
personal loan or mortgage but the cards aren't cut up.
Consolidating your credit card or other personal debt into your
mortgage has the advantage of bringing down the interest rate
you're paying - perhaps from about 20 per cent on a card to about 9
per cent on the mortgage.
But advisers say there are two other considerations.
First, debt which you would have paid off over a much shorter
term is now spread over 20 or 30 years. Even at the lower rate, you
can be worse off because of the compound interest over the longer
term.
The second consideration is that you can't lose your house over
credit card debt, because it's not secured against property - but
roll that debt into your mortgage and suddenly it's secured against
your home.
If consolidation proves to be only a short-term solution and you
really can't meet your obligations, you could default on your home
loan and be forced to sell.
Refinancing
Again, refinancing your mortgage can make sense in the right
circumstances and if you do your homework - and if you can obtain a
new loan as financial institutions tighten their lending
criteria.
For example, it may make sense for some people to switch from a
"premium" home loan package with all the bells and whistles to a
basic home loan with fewer features but a much lower interest
rate.
It's essential you do your research. According to InfoChoice
data, AMO Home Loans has the cheapest basic loan at 7.97 per cent.
But leave in the first two years - not an impossibility if you're
still struggling - and you'll be up for an exit fee of 1.2 per
cent. On $150,000, that's a penalty of $1800.
Among the big five banks, ANZ tops the list with a basic loan
rate of 8.92 per cent for borrowings of $150,000, though NAB would
pull ahead by a nose on a loan of $250,000. And, of course, you may
be up for an exit fee on your existing loan that wipes out any
benefit of refinancing.
Lowe says some of the "most awful" cases her organisation sees
involve multiple refinancings.
"Someone may have started out with a mainstream lender, got into
trouble, and they're onto their third or fourth or fifth
refinancing [with a fringe lender] by the time we see them. When
the first refinancing happened they may have had potentially
$100,000 more equity in the property but that's been stripped away
over the next three or four or five loans through a combination of
fees and various other charges.
"At the point where the consumer sees us, there's virtually
nothing left. If they'd made what is clearly a very hard decision
earlier [to sell], at least they would have something left with to
start again."
In some cases people are left with worse than nothing, after
their home sells at a price insufficient to discharge the debt
completely.
Access to super
Another option that some people have been using is getting
access to their super. This is extremely difficult to do but $175
million was released from super on hardship grounds in 2007, more
than double the $77 million released in 2005.
A member can go directly to the fund to ask for super to be
released on the grounds of "severe financial hardship" but only if
they've been receiving government income support for at least 26
weeks and they are unable to meet "reasonable and immediate" living
expenses.
Alternatively, they can apply to the Australian Prudential
Regulation Authority for the release of super on "compassionate
grounds" to meet mortgage payments if they're under threat of
foreclosure.
If such access "is genuinely going to make a difference in the
long term to a consumer keeping their home, then it can be a good
option," Lowe says. However, all too often her office finds
consumers aren't getting enough of their super or getting it in
circumstances where the home can't be saved - "then of course what
they've done is further reduced their assets," she says.
More help
The website of the financial counsellors' peak body lists
counselling services around the country; see http://www.afccra.org
/counselling.htm. If you're considering refinancing, do your sums
with the "multi-loan" calculator from the Australian Competition
and Consumer Commission; see http://www.fido.gov.au.
Financial help for a struggling artist
Painter Stacy Kershaw was tired of living up to the stereotype
of struggling artist when she and her husband decided last year
they needed to do something about their two mortgages and three
credit cards.
The bank had already upped the rate on their variable-rate home
loans a couple of times independently of the Reserve Bank and -
like everyone - she was noticing the difference when she filled up
the car and paid for the groceries.
"I was pretty much struggling financially," she says of her
situation in the past couple of years.
"I was picking up odd jobs, basically living off my husband's
wage and supplementing that with credit cards."
The couple had secured a mortgage to build their home, then
another loan to finish it off.
"We ended up with two separate payments to make and it was quite
a hefty amount to find every month," she says.
Their original mortgage came with a credit card and they kept
the one they already had. "Then we also got a separate card with
another bank that was offering a pretty low rate," Kershaw
says.
The cards were "pretty much maxed out" by the time the idea of
refinancing came up.
Today they have a single mortgage at 8.74 per cent, compared
with 8.97 per cent and 9.22 per cent on their previous two loans,
and the credit card debt has been consolidated into that loan.
Instead of making five different payments a month on loans and
cards, they're making one. The net result is that there's about
$540 a month back in the household budget.
A credit card attached to the new loan is paid off monthly.
Catch-22 on mortgage
Property investor Dawn Burke (pictured) investigated refinancing
her two mortgages only to find, in her words, there was "little or
no point".
Having watched the rate on her bank loan go up independently of
the Reserve Bank's rises, she spoke to her other lender, a credit
union, but was told its rates were also about to rise because of
the global credit crisis. She also discovered there was a $700 exit
penalty on her two-year-old bank loan.
She considered putting $20,000 onto the bank loan then having
the loan rewritten over the same period but concluded that in the
long term she'd be no better off because the smaller amount would
be paid off over a longer period than otherwise - costing more in
total interest.
"If I do this, it takes longer to pay [that sum] off - unless I
maintain the payments I currently make, which are creating quite a
headache for me. A catch-22 situation if I ever had one."
Burke, a Sydney facilitator for RadPad, which markets
eco-friendly women's products, says she has also been hurt by the
rise in the local dollar, which is eroding returns from an Auckland
investment unit.
BEST RATE BASIC HL Rates (%) Fees ($)
Institution Variable True rate Applicat. Deferred establishment fee
AMO 7.97 8.08 1000 Yrs 1-2: 1.2%, yr3: 1%, yr4: 0.8%, yr5: 0.6%
Wizard HL 8.13 8.19 760 Yrs 1: 1.5%, yr2: 1.2%, yr 3: 0.9%, yr4: 0.6%
Victoria Teachers CU 8.47 8.52 600 Yrs 1-5: 1x monthly repayment
Illawarra CU* 8.57 8.73 600 $200
Community CPS Aust# 8.6 8.75 495 NA
BIG 5 BASIC HL Rates (%) Fees ($)
Institution Variable True rate Applicat. Deferred establishment fee
ANZ 8.92 8.97 500 $700, if within 4 years
Commonwealth Bank 9.07 9.2 NIL** $700, if within 4 years
NAB 8.95^ 9 600 $900, if within 4 years
St George 8.95 9,.00 500 $1000, if within 3 years
Westpac>> 9.03 9.18 600 $700, if within 4 years
BASED ON LOAN AMOUNT OF $150,000 OVER 25 YEARS
*ANNUAL FEE OF $96 # ANNUAL FEE OF $132
**SPECIAL OFFER ESTBL. FEE NORMALLY $600 + $96 PA SERVICE FEE
^BORROWINGS
>$250,000 WILL REDUCE THE HEADLINE RATE BY 5 BASIS POINTS
>> ANNUAL FEE OF $120
SOURCE: INFOCHOICE