Perhaps the most remarkable item at the new Baggy Green
exhibition at the Bradman Museum in Bowral is the cap belonging to
Adam Craig Gilchrist, Australian Test player No. 381.
It was presented to Gilchrist on his Test debut against Pakistan
at Brisbane in November 1999. He wore it for the next 60 Tests
before reluctantly replacing it with his second and final baggy
green, worn until his retirement from Test cricket in January this
year.
Gilchrist's original cap is so worn and battered it resembles an
item of war memorabilia. It's an appropriate metaphor given the
esteem in which the baggy green is held these days. Modern players
consider them a sacred item, in some ways the sporting equivalent
of the Victoria Cross medal. As with the VC, there are some who
believe they should never be sold on the collectables market.
Gilchrist, among many of the well-paid modern players, has said he
would never sell his caps despite their obvious monetary value.
Others appear to be less emotionally attached.
Ian Chappell, for example, has not kept one of the caps he
received during his illustrious career. He didn't know where any of
his were until he was told by his friend, Ashley Mallett, that one
now sits in a glass case at the Glenelg Cricket Club in Adelaide
where he began his first-class career.
It's only recently that these symbols of Australian cricket have
been given their current status.
"Before the first sports auction held by Phillips in London in
1978, caps were generally not bought and sold but swapped or given
away," Michael Fahey writes in his new book, The Baggy Green,
co-authored with Mike Coward. Or even stolen, as happened to Greg
Chappell when a spectator removed one from his head as he was
returning to the dressing rooms at the Wanderers ground in
Johannesburg.
Before 1978, old caps were likely to turn up in flea markets or
antiques stores. Fahey reports that there have been 168 baggy
greens offered for sale during the past 16 years, resulting in 122
sales at an average of $16,893 a cap.
Five Bradman caps have appeared and these deserve a separate
category, such is their sentimental and monetary value. These
average almost $160,000 each, including the top price of $425,000
paid for the cap worn by Bradman during the Invincibles Tour of
1948. It goes without saying that this is the highest price ever
paid for a baggy green. The nearest challenger is the $180,000 paid
for another Bradman cap from his 1947-48 season. Yet it seems
remarkable that another Bradman cap sold for $7500 in 1995, an
indication of how recently this market has taken off.
Top prices paid for lesser mortals include Keith Miller's
1954-55 cap, fetching $40,775 in 2006. Victor Trumper, with results
of $28,750 (sold in 1997) and $83,000 (sold in 2004), is the
closest in stature to Bradman, at least according to auction
results. Trumper played in an era before the "baggy" style was
introduced. The colour green was also different, a darker shade
known as "gum-tree" green.
There is now considerable demand for baggy greens among sporting
collectors around the world. The value depends partly on the status
of the player who wore it and partly on when it was worn. The
Invincibles Tour of 1948 is the most prized. Regardless of
provenenace, most baggy greens now fetch more than $10,000.
This is a sharp rise from 1998 when Clarrie Grimmett's 1930 cap
sold for a mere $7475 at auction. Given his stature you'd expect
this to fetch at least triple that amount today.
The sharp rise in value is demonstrated by the progress of Colin
McDonald's 1956 cap. This was first sold by Charles Leski in
Melbourne in 1999 for $2990, then by Knight's Auctions in London in
2002 for $6571, then again by Knight's in 2005 for $7896 (all
prices in Australian dollars). According to Michael Fahey's
mathematics, that's a 264 per cent increase in six years.
Others have done even better. Wally Grout's cap achieved a 436
per cent increase in just four years.
As previously mentioned, there are those who find these figures
almost offensive, including some of the modern players. Others
insist that without private collectors and the collectables market,
many of the older caps would not have survived.
Some of those in the Bradman Museum's exhibition were freely
handed over for display by collectors, including such rarities as
the one worn by Cyril Docker when he played for the 1919 Australian
Imperial Force Team. It's navy blue with a black peak and the
rising sun emblem but few would argue that it doesn't deserve a
place in a baggy green exhibition.
There's been a surprising variety of emblem designs over the
years, including the one-off white bicentennial cap worn by the
Australian team during the lone Test against England at the SCG in
1988. Only 12 of these were produced and they rank among the most
desirable of non-green caps.
Also of interest are the baggy greens worn by Australian women
cricketers. Same cloth, same design (smaller head sizes, we assume)
but differentiated from the male of the species by a reverse-colour
riband. Belinda Clark's is on display at Bowral.
The Baggy Green exhibition continues at the Bradman Museum in
Bowral until September. All images of caps courtesy of the Bradman
Museum.
My collection
After graduating with an economics degree from the University of
Sydney, Michael Fahey worked in the finance industry before
deciding in 1993 that there was an opening in the sporting
memorabilia market. He now runs Legends Genuine Memorabilia and, to
coincide with the Bradman Museum's Baggy Green exhibition, he has
written a book, The Baggy Green. It details the history of the
Australian cricket cap as well as its second life as an
increasingly lucrative collectable.
The first baggy green Fahey bought was one belonging to Mike
Whitney, picked up in 1991 at his testimonial dinner.
Hundreds have since passed through his hands but the only one he
has kept is a baggy white, signed by the Australian team. This was
a special version produced for the 1988 Bicentennial Test in
Sydney.
Fahey's book, which includes statistics on the many caps sold at
auction since 1978, is available at bookstores as well as through
the Cricket Publishing Company and Legends Genuine Memorabilia
website (www.lgm.com.au).
$15,000; $100,000; $120,000
Ron Archer's baggy green, as worn on tour in 1954-55, last sold
for $8000 in June last year. Archer may not be a household name but
any caps from this period are increasing in value.
The great Victor Trumper is one of the few Australians to rival
Bradman in the memorabilia stakes. This cap dates back to 1899,
before the "baggy" period. It sold in August 1997 for $28,750.
Anything worn by Bradman is a blue-chip investment. The Don's
1946-47 cap sold for $88,000 in June 2003.
All estimates supplied by Michael Fahey of Legends Genuine
Memorabilia.