Try saying one-stop stock aloud three times. Give up? Never
mind, all you have to do is remember it will give you an instantly
diversified share portfolio.
And if the past two years are anything to go by, it will do
better than most share funds pushed by advisers - and deliver a
more diversified portfolio at a lower cost and with a higher
return.
Then again, who wants an instant share portfolio in this rickety
market? Well, I have it on good authority that not being in the
market, even when it's at its worst, is for losers.
None other than the Australian Securities and Investments
Commission says that over the past century, shares have scored a
return of 7.5 percent a year after inflation.
That's the same as getting 12 percent a year from an online bank
account for doing nothing. See? This is big money that compounds
over time.
The one-stop stock - oops, sorry about the spittle - is an
exchange traded fund, or what fund managers who are so attached to
their acronyms call ETFs. Bully for them, but let's settle for
one-stoppers because that's what they are.
They're no different to buying or selling ordinary shares except
they hold bits of other stocks according to how big they are.
And so the SPDR S&P/ASX200 fund will hold some of every one
of the top 200 stocks, the amount depending on what proportion of
the S&P/ASX200 index it is.
For example, Telstra shares would be 4.35 percent of the
portfolio. The same goes for a better-known index fund such as
Vanguard. But one-stoppers come into their own due to their lower
cost - unless you plan on making regular contributions - and their
ease of getting in and out of.
In fact, the only cost of buying one is the brokerage which,
depending on your broker, can be as little as $20.
The manager's fee once you're in is less than 0.3 percent,
compared with about 0.75 percent for an unlisted index fund and 1.8
percent for a share fund.
One-stoppers shouldn't be confused with listed investment
companies (LICs) which are stock pickers and would consider
mimicking an index beneath them.
Although they make a point of their investment skill, their fees
are about the same, and cheaper than a managed fund which can be as
high as 2percent a year.
The other main difference is that LICs are far more susceptible
to market sentiment and can trade well below (usually in a bull
market because everybody deserts them for whatever's hot, which
won't be them) or above (such as now) what their investments are
worth.
So investing in one of the leading, long-established LICs would
cost you slightly more than buying the shares in some cases, even
allowing for what brokerage would cost you.
But one-stoppers can never get out of whack. Their prices cling
to the value of the underlying investments because whenever there's
a rush of sellers or buyers, shares can be created or cancelled as
the case may be. Hmm. Why can't they do that for all stocks? Oh,
silly me, it would take all the fun away, of course.
Remember, because one-stoppers hug the index, they have to buy
the good with the bad whereas LICs can be more choosy.
By the same token, there's no chance of human error in a
one-stopper, either. The fact that they can be bought and sold
easily like other shares can also be a drawback.
No less than the world's most famous and successful investor,
Warren Buffett, who is also an old-fashioned kind of guy, prefers
ordinary old index funds to the new-fangled ETFs on account of the
fact there's less temptation to trade them.
By the way, he says you should invest in little chunks at a time
so as not to run the risk of getting your timing wrong and paying
too much, but this can make one-stoppers dearer because you're up
for brokerage every time. Both would seem to have it over other
kinds of managed funds where about 2percent a year is gobbled up in
fees and so start behind the eight ball.
As it turns out, just over half of actively managed share funds
do better than a passive index fund, which means that your chances
of finding a fund that will significantly outperform the index over
time is roughly 50-50.
And that's ignoring the fact that the best performing funds tend
to switch around over time, making it well nigh impossible to guess
which one will do well in what year.
There are three alternative one-stoppers covering the Australian
sharemarket to choose from. Through State Street Global Advisers,
you can track either the top 50 (SFY) or 200 (STW) as well as the
top 200 listed property trusts (SLF).
One-stoppers pay a good dividend most of the time - at the
moment the dividend yield is almost 6.5percent, partially franked -
but you wouldn't want to set your budget around them.
The most recent payout from the ASX50 was 102 cents, compared
with 226 cents for the previous one.
Dividend franking fluctuated between 24 and 83percent over the
past three years for no apparent rhyme or reason.
Still, a handy strategy is to use them as a core, diversified
portfolio to which you can later add specific stocks if you want
to.
But they also come into their own in a volatile market like this
where plunging in at the wrong time could prove very costly, while
staying out entirely risks missing out altogether when it
recovers.
The idea is to park your money and see what happens. If the
market is rising, you're ahead and if it falls, you haven't lost as
much as you may have on individual stocks.
That's because broadly diversified portfolios never suffer as
much as individual stocks can in a downturn.
Come to that, if you want to gear, one-stoppers are also safer
than individual stocks.
Safer still would be to go into ETFs at regular intervals rather
than in one hit.
Apart from providing a share portfolio straight off the peg,
they can also give you an instant asset allocation if you're
prepared to venture a bit further. You can put together a portfolio
of shares from Australia, China, emerging economies and big names
with them.
Weird as it sounds, you can trade the indexes of other
sharemarkets on the ASX with iShares.Offered by Barclays Global
Investors, iShares come in 14 flavours (listed in the table).
Annual fees range from just 0.09 to 0.74percent.
DIY super funds love them, especially the iShares Xinhua/FTSE 25
(code IZZ) which consists of 25 Class H and red-chip shares trading
on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and has returned an average
25percent a year since it started in November 2004.
Apart from the spectacular return, the attraction of iShares is
that they give a bite of the emerging markets without a huge
outlay. One IZZ share costs about $150, compared with a typical
minimum investment of $20,000.
If you're really daring you can even buy other exchanges'
exchanges. Er, I mean you can buy iShares listed on another
exchange as distinct from iShares of another exchange listed
here.
Whatever, the fact is you can buy iShares in sectors that
Australia doesn't have - technology and pharmaceuticals, for
instance - by buying a foreign iShare through our stock
exchange.
Some other markets are also covered by foreign iShares such as
Mexico, South Africa, Chile and Brazil.
There are even special iShares for gold and silver.
And don't forget, all iShares carry a currency risk, so you're
taking a long-term punt that our dollar will fall.
HOW THEY COMPARE
Listed investment company ETF Share fund Index fund
Tax effective Yes Yes No Yes
Manager fees Low Low High Low
Volatile prices Yes Yes No Yes
Diversification Low High Medium High
Easy to quit Yes Yes No Yes
Adds value Yes No Yes No
Entry fee Brokerage only Brokerage only Yes Yes
Exit fee Brokerage only Brokerage only Yes No
Adviser linked No No Yes No
14 FLAVOURS
Share ASX code What it covers Fee (%)
Global 100 IOO Global blue chips 0.4
MSCI EAFE IVE Europe, Australia, Far East 0.34
Europe 350 IEU 350 stocks in UK, Europe 0.6
S&P 500 IVV 500 largest US stocks 0.09
S&P Midcap IJH 400 US middle-size stocks 0.2
S&P Smallcap IJR 600 US small stocks 0.2
Russell 2000 IRU 2000 small US stocks 0.2
MSCI Japan IJP Japanese shares 0.52
MSCI Hong Kong IHK Hong Kong shares 0.52
MSCI Singapore ISG Singapore shares 0.51
MSCI Emerging IEM Global emerging markets 0.74
MSCI Taiwan ITW Taiwanese shares 0.68
MSCI South Korea IKO South Korean shares 0.68
FTSE/Xinhua IZZ Top 25 Chinese stocks 0.74