In November 2006, Sotheby's New York sold 14,000 bottles from
the celebrated Park B. Smith collection, with the focus on
Bordeaux, Rhone and California. It had a significant number of
large-format bottles, particularly magnums and double magnums.
The big-ticket item was 50 cases of Chateau Mouton Rothschild
1982, sold as one lot. These sold for $US1,051,600, a world record
for a wine lot sold at auction. In total, the collection fetched
$US5,320,000.
Such prices may be above the budget of the average wine drinker
but there is also growing interest in collecting vintage wine
labels and these are somewhat cheaper. The labels can be attached
to the empty bottle, or loose, depending on the collector's
preference. Those blessed with a cellar may like to have a row of
empty bottles, the more distinguished the better, displayed on a
shelf. These are the bottles they aspire to owning in the full
state one day. Others keep the labels filed in folders in the
manner of stamps.
It is possible to find labels 100 years old in mint condition.
These may be the surplus from a particular vintage that were never
used. Some labels were printed in greater quantities than required,
then used for promotional purposes. It was once possible to pick
these up as souvenirs from the cellar door. For whatever reason,
wine labels are out there in large enough quantities for them to be
collectable.
Their value depends largely on the value of the bottle they
identified. Those for the previously mentioned Chateau Mouton
Rothschild are, not surprisingly, very much in demand. The golden
period for collectors is the Art Collection series, starting in
1945, during which artists from Pablo Picasso to Andy Warhol
supplied original artwork for the top third of the label. This
series has been featured in a book, Mouton Rothschild: Paintings
For The Labels, 1945-1981, published by Little, Brown and
Company.
There are examples by Salvador Dali (1958) and Henry Moore
(1964). Recently a collection of more than 20 of these labels sold
for about $3000 on eBay. As with stamps, a complete collection is
worth a lot more than single examples. And as with the full
bottles, you pay more for a magnum label - about $150 is the
norm.
This market works in much the same way as stamps. Significant
rarities will fetch more, such as the Bourgogne 1974 label, which
bears the symbol of the Confrerie des Chevaliers du Tastevin, one
of the most prestigious stamps of approval in France.
Some collectors concentrate on a single theme. One of the more
popular is absinthe, that potent spirit that was banned in France
in 1913, supposedly because of its poisonous nature.
Such is the romantic history of this drink that there are many
who collect the associated paraphernalia, especially the glasses
and perforated spoons used to drip sugar into the notoriously
bitter concoction. Absinthe labels are especially prized, worth
between $50 to $100, depending on condition. Spoons range from $50
to $1000 for sterling silver examples.
There are also Australian label rarities such as those from the
Camden Park winery, established by James and William Macarthur,
which are dated to before 1867. In this case, an empty bottle could
be worth as much as a full one, considering that the contents would
be undrinkable by now. Empty bottles from all the early vineyards,
such as Yerinberg in the Yarra Valley, are now considered
collectable.
There are ways of removing labels but the general rule is to
leave them on if that's how they are found, especially if the
bottle has the patina of age.
An excellent source for anyone interested in this subject is the
State Library of South Australia which has been collecting wine
labels since the early 1970s. Its archive is thought to be the best
in the Southern Hemisphere, if not the world. The emphasis is on
South Australian wines, especially the Barossa Valley, but other
states and the world are also represented. Links to the wine
history archive are on the library's website and images of landmark
labels are posted, including a surprisingly basic 1955 Penfolds
Grange label with the important details added by typewriter.
A complete collection of labels for a wine such as Grange is now
seen as a good investment. The Queen Adelaide series (starting in
1953) is considered significant, as are early labels for Woodley
Treasure Chest Claret and Wynn's Coonawarra. These are valued for
their elaborate design as well as their part in wine history.
This is a relatively new area of collecting, especially in
Australia. It's a reflection of our culture that the collecting of
beer labels is much more established here. In France, there is now
a growing fad for collecting champagne muzzles, those identifying
metal caps that are connected to the cork with wire. For an
interesting collection of these, see
http://www.glyphjockey.com.
My collection
Vintage wine and food authority John Cunnington has been
collecting old and rare labels for most of his life and is only now
realising their potential value. He says he knows of few other
collectors in Australia but has noticed a general increase in
interest in Europe, the US and Japan.
Among his personal collection is a mint set of Queen Adelaide
labels, found several years ago in a junk shop. He also has some
rare, unused absinthe labels that were found in Paris and
complement his collection of absinthe spoons and glasses.
These days, John runs his food and wine paraphernalia shop as an
online business. If you want a vintage foie gras container or a
traditional duck press, see http://www.artwinefood.com.au.
$50
Early labels for Australian landmark wines such as Queen
Adelaide are now rare in mint condition. This is the first vintage,
from 1953.
$100
This 1974 Bourgogne label is significant because of its
endorsement by the prestigious Confrerie des Chevaliers. Some
European collectors specialise in this area.
$250
The collection of absinthe memorabilia is a worldwide
phenomenon. Original labels are especially prized (valued from $50
to $100), while the perforated sugar spoons can be worth up to
$1000 each.