In an unregulated industry, you have to do your own
homework.
If you're about to buy your first home or are trading up to a
bigger property and acquiring more debt, how do you know whether
your mortgage broker is getting the best possible deal for you? The
industry remains largely unregulated, there are hundreds of lenders
and although consumers tend to be better educated than they were a
decade ago, financial services are more complex.
"It's not easy," says Peter Hayward, Citibank's head of mortgage
distribution. "But do your homework, know what you want and, if
you're not sure, get a second opinion."
Hayward firmly believes that the power to get the best deal
resides with the consumer.
"The borrower should start with some idea of what they need," he
says. "Getting a home loan is a big deal. But if anything is
unclear, the consumer can go to the lender, which is where the
contract ends up, or back to the broker."
Warren Shaw, National Australia Bank's general manager of
mortgages, says: "Anyone who thinks we've got the power is mistaken
- the customer has the power."
An accommodating attitude from the banks means customers don't
have to settle for a standard loan. Hayward says few banks push
loans on low rates alone. "It's been about the bells and whistles
for some time," he says.
Tim Brown, the head of Macquarie Mortgages, says Macquarie
offers a range of sophisticated mortgages. "Our clients want
flexibility. A good broker is going to be able to assess a client's
needs and get them a product that suits."
Loans with multiple features often come with higher interest
rates. "Do you need a high-cost loan?" Hayward asks. "Make sure
you're certain that what you're offered meets your needs."
Regulated at last
State ministers are continuing their drive toward uniform
regulation for Australia's mortgage brokers.
A spokesman for the NSW Fair Trading Minister, Diane Beamer,
says the proposed reforms are still in the draft stage but all
states are close to agreeing the format.
The draft bill is likely to include the following reforms:
Brokers to undergo probity checks.
They must be members of an approved alternative dispute
resolution scheme.
They must have a certain level of specific skills and improve
those skills continually as a condition of their licence.
Brokers will neither be allowed to charge upfront fees nor be
able to lodge caveats over property to secure those fees.
Consumers have access to redress that takes into account losses
where an inappropriate product has been recommended.
There will be provision for a stay of enforcement in relation to
the borrower's primary residence where damages are being claimed
from a broker.
They must have indemnity insurance.
Brokers will also have to disclose the cost of new loans and
services before broking an agreement with a borrower. A broking
agreement must contain specific details of the client's needs and
state why a particular product was recommended. And there must be a
reasonable basis for a broker making any recommendation.
There is also hope that the wording of the legislation might go
some way towards protecting consumers who take out a reverse
mortgage.
"I expect the first draft to be published within the first six
months of this year," says Phil Naylor, the head of the brokers'
industry body, the Mortgage and Finance Association of
Australia.
"Regulation will make a big difference to the way the industry
works. The best we can do as an industry body is expel people who
don't abide by our code of conduct.
"They still operate. They don't operate in the best environment
but they are still out there.
"Regulation means people operating on the sidelines will be
dealt with."