At this time of year, some investors and commentators can get a
bit giddy with what is commonly known to investors as the "January
effect" - and they do have an argument.
Whether you put it down to science or superstition, the fact is
since 1970 the sharemarket's All Ordinaries Index has returned an
average 11.2 per cent between December 1 and May 31, compared with
2.5 per cent between June 1 and November 30.
Shane Oliver, AMP Capital's head of investment strategy, says
this effect means it is generally good to invest between November
to May, as that's when the market puts in its best returns.
"I wouldn't recommend that investors solely trade on the back of
seasonal factors, but it is certainly an indicator worth looking
at," he says.
The reason for the January effect has long been debated among
traders, but no definitive answer has been found.
Many think it is due to tax-selling in the United States, the
world's largest market, which has a flow-on effect around the
globe.
The tax sell-off to realise capital losses kicks off with the US
mutual funds in October and continues until the end of the tax year
in December, as other institutional and retail investors
crystallise their losses.
Of course, much of this money needs to be reinvested, so after a
slight dip in the market, funds come rushing back, driving prices
higher once again.
Likewise, many large corporations pay big contributions to their
staffs' pension fund at year end, which is usually invested in
January.
Add to this the Christmas bonuses that are often invested in the
market come January, and a clear argument starts to emerge for the
reason the market picks up early each year.
"Seasonal patterns are useful in timing moves into and out of
the market," Oliver says. "If you want to allocate money into the
market now is not a bad time to do it, but I would think twice
about putting a lot of money in around May.
"Likewise, if you are thinking of taking money out, then October
and September are probably not a good time to do it."
Much as the environment can affect seasonal climate patterns,
changes in the financial environment can also effect the
sharemarket's seasonal differences.
"People do tend to sell out of their trading positions [at this
time of year] because there is no momentum, so there may be some
opportunities around," says Marcus Padley, a Tolhurst Noall share
broker and publisher of the daily newsletter Marcus Today. "But to
generalise too much is to offer a level of comfort that could
change in a day".
Padley and CMC market analyst David Land say any "January
effect" could easily be negated by the flood of super money shoring
up share prices at a time when the market is regularly breaking
historic highs. It is, and will remain, a stock-pickers market,
they say.
"I am generally wary of putting fixed rules on what the market
will do because historically it has a habit of surprising us," Land
says.
He argues that growing awareness of the January effect has
pulled forward buying and selling in anticipation of the end of the
US tax year.
"I would be happier seeing people making their buying and
selling decisions based on company fundamentals rather than the
anticipation of a strong buy up following tax selling in the US,"
Land says.
Oliver says that while investors should note the seasonal
patterns, they are not guaranteed and do not replace the knowledge
and research needed to make a good investment decision.