But when we're talking football, the heart almost always rules
the head. How else can one explain people's passionate, lifelong
attachment to one team and their misery when the side loses?
So it's not too surprising when Max Williamson, the head of the
sports department at Charles Leski Auctions in Melbourne, says
there is one big difference between collectors of football
memorabilia and other sports collectors: that "most [football
fanatics] only collect things associated with their own club". "In
cricket people collect cricket items generally," he says, "but in
football, in all the codes we can think of, most people only
collect their own club.
"I suppose the exceptions are with rugby union - people collect
Wallabies items because people are representing their country, or
All Black items, things like that. But in rugby league and
Australian rules, most people only want things to do with the club
they support."
This makes football collecting - in league, union, Aussie rules
and
soccer - a much narrower market, but that's good news for
collectors: it means the demand for a famous or historical item
from a certain football club is never going to be as great as it
might be for other sports.
The number of potential buyers is smaller, so what's on offer
will be relatively cheap - hundreds of dollars, or perhaps a few
thousand, rather than the stratospheric amounts in other
disciplines.
There are exceptions, of course. Williamson says only a handful
of the most prestigious award for Australian rules players, the
Brownlow Medal, have been put up for sale. The first was sold in
2000, and fetched more than $70,000. Others sold
for less, but it's still a huge lure to any buyer who loves his
footy club.
Prices for British and European football items can also be
tremendously high, thanks to the larger number of fans worldwide.
Earlier this year the oldest surviving FA Cup, presented to winning
teams between 1896 and 1910, was sold by Christie's in London for
£420,000 ($973,000) - a world record for a sporting item.
Thankfully, potential collectors in Australia are looking at
much more realistic prices. Rare football cards from cigarette or
chewing gum packets can sell for $250 to $300 each, Williamson
says, but "most of the football cards are between $1 and $5 each,
so you can get a pretty good collection together without spending a
tremendous amount of money".
Old programs for matches or tours, while increasingly sought
after, are not out of reach. Programs from the Wallabies' 1908 tour
to England, during which the team won the gold medal at the London
Olympics, can fetch up to $1000.
Williamson advises new collectors to contact their club first
and look at the modern
range of memorabilia such as framed jerseys, signed posters and
photographs.
"People start with things they can put on the wall, but what
usually happens is the wall fills up fairly quickly and they start
to collect things they can [put] in albums,"
he says. "That's one of the reasons that things like the old
football cards and programs are very popular now, because you can
put together a fabulous collection without taking up too much
space."
Starter guide
$175
Limited edition football made to celebrate the Sydney Swans 2005
grand final win. Made of leather by Sherrin. From Sydney Swans
website: http://www.afl.com.au/swans
$1000
Original newspaper poster from 1967, celebrating Richmond's AFL
premiership win. Signed "WEG" by cartoonist Bill Green. Sold last
month through Charles Leski Auctions, Melbourne.
$1850
Signed and mounted jerseys from the 2003 soccer match between
England and Australia in London, which Australia won 3-1.
Signatures include David Beckham and Harry Kewell. Sold last month
through Charles Leski Auctions, Melbourne.
$2695
One of a limited edition of 31 rugby league NSW State of Origin
guernseys signed by Brad Fittler, celebrating 25 years of the State
of Origin series. Sold through http://www.lgm.com.au
$973,000
Oldest existing FA Cup, presented to winning teams from 1896 to
1910. The first to come up for sale, it achieved a world record
price when sold in May by Christie's in London.
My collection
Russell Fogarty
There's no need to ask Russell Fogarty why he's such an
enthusiastic collector of memorabilia from the South Melbourne and
Sydney Swans: his family's support for the team goes back three
generations.
The collection started with Fogarty's father, who at the age of
12 managed to get the autograph of every Swans player involved in
the 1945 grand final. Fogarty still has this memento, but it's not
the oldest item in his collection by a long way. "We won our first
premiership in 1909 and all the players were presented with a gold
premiership medallion," he says. "I've got one of those medallions,
so that's nearly 97 years old ... it's a great piece and I'm rapt I
got it. I've also got four best and fairest [awards] for the South
Melbourne Football Club, they're from the 1930s, and I've got a
1933 premiership medallion."
That might sound like a lot in itself, but this is just
scratching the surface of Fogarty's collection. He has historic and
recent photographs, vintage footy cards and countless guernseys
worn by famous Swans players, including the 200th game guernsey of
former captain Paul Kelly, one worn by Adam Goodes the year he won
the Brownlow Medal, and a limited edition framed guernsey
celebrating this year's grand final win.
The most impressive items in the collection, however, are the
Brownlow Medals won by Fred Goldsmith in 1955 and "Herbie" Matthews
in 1940. Only a few Brownlows have ever come up for sale, Fogarty
says, and he remembers his purchase in 2000 of Goldsmith's medal
from Christie's, for $43,700, as "the first really expensive thing
I had bought".